Can Cats Eat Cookies? A Feline Conundrum For The Baking Season

Cats helping baking, cats eating cookies
Image Credit: Deposit Photos.

Picture this: your feline friend looking at you with those pleading eyes as you enjoy a plate of cookies. The temptation to share might be strong, but before you indulge your cat’s curiosity, let’s delve into the question:

Can Cats Eat Cookies?

Cats should not eat cookies or any food out of their normal diet. Proper food is required not only for nutrition but also for their health and overall well-being. However, as one might sneak a treat or two during the baking session below, we look at common ingredients cookies may contain that are harmful or not for your cat. 

What Are Cookies Made Of?

Cat looking up at camera and oatmeal raisin cookies
Image Credit: Deposit Photos.

Cookies, or biscuits, are delightful treats for humans, but their ingredients may not align with a cat’s dietary needs. Flour, sugar, eggs, oil, and butter form the core of cookie dough. While cats can handle small amounts of flour and eggs, the real danger lies in additional flavorings.

Common Cookie Toppings

Cookie toppings, like chocolate chips, raisins, and nuts can be toxic to cats. Some cookies also contain xylitol, a sugar replacement that is highly poisonous for our feline friends (and dogs!).

Chart of Common Cookie Toppings

ToppingHarmful for Cats
Chocolate chipsYes (toxic)
AlmondYes (in moderation)
White chocolateYes (toxic)
PecanYes (toxic in large quantities)
ButterscotchYes (toxic)
FrostingNo
RaisinYes (toxic)
Cream cheeseYes (in moderation)
Peanut butterYes (in moderation)
PeppermintNo
RaspberryNo
Chocolate dipYes (toxic)

Typical Cookie Ingredients

While the core ingredients might not harm a cat in small doses, other typical cookie ingredients could. Here is a chart of other ingredients one might use while baking cookies and their associated harmfulness to our feline friends.

Chart of Typical Cookie Ingredients

IngredientHarmful for Cats
Peanut butterYes (in moderation)
AlmondYes (in moderation)
CinnamonNo
ButterNo
ChocolateYes (toxic)
CrunchyNo
Granulated sugarNo
MeltedNo
FlourNo
OatsNo
Vanilla extractNo
Brown sugarNo
ShorteningNo
SugarsNo
Semi-sweet chocolateNo
Baking sodaNo
Semi-sweetNo
Powdered sugarNo
Dark brown sugarNo
Chocolate chip cookie doughYes (toxic)
Baking powderNo
Dark chocolateYes (toxic)
RaisinYes (toxic)
Gluten-freeNo
TeaspoonsNo
GingerNo
CocoaYes (toxic)
MacaroonsNo
BiscottiNo
MeringueNo
ShortbreadYes (in moderation)
CoconutNo
DoughNo
SyrupNo
UnsaltedNo
SnickerdoodleNo
CranberriesNo
CranberryNo
GranolaNo
Shortbread cookieYes (in moderation)
RaspberryNo
MuffinsNo
CakesNo
PreheatNo
Dark brown sugarNo
Chocolate chip cookie doughYes (toxic)
MacaroonsNo
OatNo
BiscottiNo
MeringueNo
Thumbprint cookiesNo
ToffeeNo
ThumbprintNo
Oatmeal chocolate chip cookiesNo
FudgeNo
WalnutsNo
Whole wheat flourNo
ToffeeNo
PistachioNo
MorselsNo
NutmegNo

Always consult with your veterinarian before feeding a pet something new!

Cats, as obligate carnivores, thrive on protein-rich diets. Cookies, being high in carbohydrates and lacking essential nutrients, can lead to weight gain and feline obesity.

What Are The Risks Of Feeding Cookies to Cats?

cat eating cookies
Image Credit: Deposit Photos.

Feeding cookies to cats can result in various health problems. The specific risks include vomiting, diarrhea, stomach upset, and weight gain. Moreover, cookies pose a potential choking hazard for cats, raising the stakes even further.

What Happens If My Cat Eats Cookies?

In the unfortunate event that your cat ingests cookies, identifying the ingredients is crucial. Check the nutritional facts label, and if any toxic components are present, contact your veterinarian immediately.

What Can I Give My Cat Instead Of Cookies?

cat helping bake.
Image Credit: Deposit Photos.

Opt for healthier alternatives to cookies that cater to your cat’s nutritional needs. Treats like catnip, plain yogurt, and cooked chicken or fish offer a safe and enjoyable snacking experience. However, always consult with your veterinarian to ensure these choices align with your cat’s specific dietary requirements.

Skip the Cookies, Choose Healthier Treats!

It is not advisable to feed cookies to cats due to the potential harm associated with their ingredients. Cats have distinct dietary needs, and offering them cookies regularly can lead to adverse health effects. To keep your feline companion happy and healthy, opt for treats that align with their carnivorous nature.

Corey Turner
Corey Turner, owner of FurBallFun.com, draws on a lifelong love for dogs and extensive pet ownership to offer a unique perspective in the pet industry. With a successful background in project management, he excels in critical analysis, precise attention to detail, and quality assurance. This expertise allows him to effectively differentiate true value from marketing hype in the pet sector. Corey’s contributions have been featured in various publications including Rockery Press Guide Books and WealthofGeeks.com. During his free time, he enjoys disc golfing, rock climbing, and bonding with his cherished FurBall friend, Harvey.